Felicia Hemans: The Sceptic (1820)
Born Felicia Dorothea Browne in 1793 in Liverpool, where her maternal grandfather was the Imperial and Tuscan Consul, Felicia Hemans lived for most of her life at St Asaph in North Wales, and died in 1835 in Dublin, where one of her brothers was Chief Police Commissioner. Gifted with a phenomenal memory, she was taught French, Italian, Spanish and Portugese by her mother, and Latin by the local vicar. Subsequently she learned German. She published her first volume at fourteen, her subjects unambitiously pastoral and domestic. The predatory Shelley – Southey’s doppelgänger – read the book, and tried to open a correspondence, sensing in its authoress a potential Cythna for his own Laon. He was rebuffed, first by Felicia herself, and then, when he insisted, by Mrs Browne.
Hemans’ life depended for its security on support from the generations before and after her own. In 1812 she had married Captain Alfred Hemans, an Irishman who had seen Peninsular service with the King’s Own Foot. Wounded in the retreat to Corunna, imperfectly mended, and retired without pay, he walked out on his family in 1818, went to Italy, and never came back. Hemans’ father had done the same, except that he’d gone to Canada.
Mystery is commonly said to surround the Captain’s departure: maybe he just saw that, his stud-role being fulfilled (his wife bore five sons) there was no other in which he could be accommodated. Maybe his health just wasn’t up to any more work in that line. Evidence suggests that he was, as Lady Byron claimed to be, shamed by his spouse’s versifying, and that he found her capacity to earn from it a humiliation. Whatever the case, he had the power, as a man, to leave. Hemans seems in any case to have been happier as daughter, sister and parent than as wife: she idolised her own mother (though she claimed Joanna Baillie as her “poetic mother”). She outlived Mrs Browne by only eight years, and put as much into her own maternal role as she did into writing. She would have preferred daughters to sons, though – sons grew up and left more quickly.
Hemans (“Hemmuns” is now the preferred pronunciation, “Hea-muns” lending itself too readily to Byronic puns – “Hewoman”, and so on) rapidly became aware of her own earning power, as a means of paying for her sons’ education. She was in consequence an unscrupulous poetic parasite on events, political and literary. Had several score Suliote women thrown themselves and their children over a cliff, to escape the soldiers of Ali Pacha? Hemans would write a poem about it. Was Silvio Pellico out of prison? She would write a poem about that. Was George III dead at last? A still more respectable opportunity to versify. Had Hobhouse and Foscolo created a curiosity about Italian poetry? She would translate some Monti (extracts only); or some Alfieri (extracts only); she would translate a sonnet of Filicaija – the same one Byron put into Childe Harold IV, except that she translated it a year earlier than he. Of such as this last, Francis Jeffrey wrote approvingly in the Edinburgh Review that “she has preserved … the tenderness and simplicity of the early Italians, without their diffuseness and languor”. His review had started cryptically, “Women, I fear, cannot do everything”.
In The Sceptic (1820), Hemans gives us nothing so vulgar as the portrait of an actual historical sceptic; no Voltaires, no Bayles, no Humes, no Gibbons, darken her chaste verses. There are no scenes of death-bed terror, no tests of “sceptical faith” dramatised. Such things would bring her poem down to earth with a bump and subject her thesis to just the kind of factual, three-dimensional imagining and analysis as create scepticism in the first place; and to depict the kind of wicked activity, which according to the theory, goes with scepticism, runs the risk of making the sin more attractive than the punishment is terrifying. But subtextual suggestion abounds, with many of the early examples, as I hope my notes will show, directed at Byron, or at least at his works.
The fact that Byron was by no means a whole-hearted sceptic, and that much of his mental energy went into exploring different avenues to faith, would not have been known to Hemans at the date of the poem’s composition, nor would she have cared if it had been. Her poem is carefully crafted for a conservative market, and written to please the kind of conservative mentality which demands rhetoric above everything else: the kind of readership, in other words, which demands social reassurance rather than spiritual challenge. No-one predisposed to spiritual smugness will be shaken out of it by The Sceptic; and for anyone inclined towards scepticism already, the poem will only increase their predilection.
John Murray published The Sceptic, as if atoning for having published Don Juan I and II in the previous year. Of her poem Hemans had written to Gifford:
… it is entirely free from political allusions, and is merely meant as a picture of the dangers resulting to public and private virtue and happiness, from the doctrines of Infidelity …1
Byron’s verse was rarely free from political allusions – any more than Hemans’, whose last sections here hymn England fulsomely – and he reacted to The Sceptic as if challenged:
Mrs. Hemans is a poet also – but too stiltified, & apostrophic – & quite wrong – men died calmly before the Christian era – & since without Christianity – witness the Romans – & lately Thistlewood – Sandt – & Louvel – men who ought to have been weighed down with their crimes – even had they believed. – – A deathbed is a matter of nerves & constitution – & not of religion; – Voltaire was frightened – Frederick of Prussia not. – Christians the same according to their strength rather than their creed.2
Arthur Thistlewood was one of the so-called “Cato Street Conspirators”, themselves the victims of a Home Office stunt, but still opposed in politics and religion to everything the “a-political” (that is to say, Tory) Hemans’ poetry advertised itself as standing for. Sandt and Louvel had killed Kotzebue and the duc de Berri. Louvel had intended to kill all the Bourbons. That Byron should drag in such irrelevant assassins may be a sign that he’s panicking.
The Sceptic was given some very positive reviews. Here is an extract from one, which expends as much ink on what the poem might have been like, as on what it is:
She has, in the poem before us, made choice of a subject of which it would have been very difficult to have reconciled the treatment, in the hands of some female authors, to the delicacy which belongs to the sex, and the tenderness and enthusiasm which form its finest characteristic. A coarse and chilling cento of the exploded fancies of modern scepticism, done into rhyme by the hand of a woman, would have been doubly disgusting by the revival of absurdities long consigned to oblivion, and by the revolting exhibition of a female mind, shorn of all its attractions, and wrapt in darkness and defiance. But Mrs. Hemans has chosen the better and the nobler cause, and while she has left in the poem before us every trace of vigorous intellect of which the subject admitted, and has far transcended in energy of thought the prosing pioneers of unbelief, she has sustained throughout a tone of warm and confiding piety.3
Felicia Hemans became, in terms of sales, the most successful English-language poet of the nineteenth century. Her ascendancy shows the kind of pious cant in reaction to which Byron wrote from 1816 onwards.
THE SCEPTIC
When the young Eagle, with exulting eye, | |
Has learn’d to dare the splendor of the sky, | |
And leave the Alps beneath him in his course, | |
To bathe his crest in morn’s empyreal source, | |
Will his free wing, from that majestic height, | |
Descend to follow some wild meteor’s light, | |
Which far below, with evanescent fire, | |
Shines to delude, and dazzles to expire?4 | |
No! still thro’ clouds he wins his upward way | |
And proudly claims his heritage of day! | 10 |
—And shall the spirit, on whose ardent gaze, | |
The day-spring from on high hath pour’d its blaze, | |
Turn from that pure effulgence, to the beam | |
Of earth-born light, that sheds a treacherous gleam, | |
Luring the wanderer from the star of faith, | |
To the deep valley of the shades of death?5 | |
What bright exchange, what treasure shall be given, | |
For the high birth-right of its hope in Heaven? | |
If lost the gem which empires could not buy, | |
What yet remains?—a dark eternity! | 20 |
Is earth still Eden?—might a Seraph guest, | |
Still, midst its chosen bowers delighted rest?6 | |
Is all so cloudless and so calm below, | |
We seek no fairer scenes than life can show? | |
That the cold Sceptic, in his pride elate, | |
Rejects the promise of a brighter state, | |
And leaves the rock, no tempests shall displace, | |
To rear his dwelling on the quicksand’s base?7 | |
Votary of doubt! Then join the festal throng, | |
Bask in the sunbeam, listen to the song, | 30 |
Spread the rich board, and fill the wine-cup high8 | |
And bind the wreath ere yet the roses die! | |
’Tis well, thine eye is yet undimm’d by time, | |
And thy heart bounds, exulting in its prime; | |
Smile then unmov’d at Wisdom’s warning voice, | |
And, in the glory of thy strength, rejoice! | |
But life hath sterner tasks; e’en youth’s brief hours, | |
Survive the beauty of their loveliest flowers; | |
The founts of joy, where pilgrims rest from toil, | |
Are few and distant on the desert soil; | 40 |
The soul’s pure fame the breath of storms must fan, | |
And pain and sorrow claim their nursling—Man! | |
Earth’s noblest sons the bitter cup have shar’d—9 | |
Proud child of reason! How art thou prepar’d? | |
When years, with silent night, thy frame have bow’d,10 | |
And o’er thy spirit cast their wintry cloud, | |
Will Memory soothe thee on thy bed of pain, | |
With the bright images of pleasure’s train? | |
Yes! as the sight of some far distant shore, | |
Whose well-known scenes his foot shall tread no more, | 50 |
Would cheer the seaman, by the eddying wave | |
Drawn, vain struggling, to th’unfathom’d grave!11 | |
Shall Hope, the faithful cherub, hear thy call, | |
She, who like Heaven’s own sunbeam, smiles for all? | |
Will she speak comfort?—Thou hast shorn her plume, | |
That might have rais’d thee far above the tomb, | |
And hush’d the only voice whose angel tone | |
Soothes when all melodies of joy are flown! | |
For she was born beyond the stars to soar, | |
And kindling at the source of life, adore; | 60 |
Thou couldst not, mortal! Rivet to the earth | |
Her eye, whose beam is of celestial birth; | |
She dwells with those who leave her pinion free, | |
And sheds the dews of heaven on all but thee. | |
Yet few there are, so lonely, so bereft, | |
But some true heart, that beats to theirs, is left, | |
And, haply, one whose strong affections power | |
Unchang’d may triumph through misfortune’s hour, | |
Still with fond care supports thy languid head, | |
And keeps unwearied vigils by thy bed. | 70 |
But thou! whose thoughts have no blessed home above, | |
Captive of earth, and canst thou dare to love? | |
To nurse such feelings as delight to rest, | |
Within that hallow’d shrine—a parent’s breast, | |
To fix each hope, concentrate every tie, | |
On one frail idol,—destined but to die, | |
Yet mock the faith that points to worlds of light, | |
Where sever’d souls, made perfect, re-unite? | |
Then tremble! cling to every passing joy, | |
Twin’d with the life a moment may destroy! | 80 |
If there be sorrow in a parting tear, | |
Still let “for ever” vibrate in thine ear!12 | |
If some bright hour on rapture’s wing hath flown, | |
Find more than anguish in the thought—’tis gone! | |
Go! to a voice such magic influence give, | |
Thou canst not lose its melody, and live; | |
And make an eye the lode-star of thy soul, | |
And let a glance the springs of thought controul; | |
Gaze on a mortal form with fond delight, | |
Till the fair vision mingles with thy sight; | 90 |
There seek thy blessings, there repose thy trust, | |
Lean on the willow, idolize the dust! | |
Then, when thy treasure best repays thy care, | |
Think on that dread “for ever”—and despair!13 | |
And oh! no strange, unwonted storm there needs, | |
To wreck at once thy fragile ark of reeds. | |
Watch well its course—explore with anxious eye, | |
Each little cloud that floats along the sky – | |
Is the blue canopy serenely fair? | |
Yet may the thunderbolt unseen be there, | 100 |
And the bark sink, when peace and sunshine sleep | |
On the smooth bosom of the waveless deep! | |
Yes! ere a sound, a sign, announce thy fate, | |
May the blow fall which makes thee desolate! | |
Not always heaven’s destroying angel shrouds | |
His awful form in tempests and in clouds, | |
He fills the summer-air with latent power, | |
He hides his venom in the scented flower, | |
He steals upon thee in the Zephyr’s breath, | |
And festal garlands veil the shafts of death! | 110 |
Where art thou then, who thus didst rashly cast | |
Thine all upon the mercy of the blast, | |
And vainly hope the tree of life14 to find | |
Rooted in sands that flit before the wind? | |
Is not that earth thy spirit lov’d so well, | |
It wish’d not in a brighter sphere to dwell, | |
Beome a desert now, a vale of gloom, | |
O’ershadow’d with the midnight of the tomb? | |
Where shalt thou turn?—it is not thine to raise | |
To yon pure heaven, thy calm confiding gaze, | 120 |
No gleam reflected from that realm of rest, | |
Steals on the darkness of thy troubled breast, | |
Not for thine eye shall Faith divinely shed | |
Her glory round the image of the dead; | |
And if, when slumber’s lonely couch is prest, | |
The form departed be thy spirit’s guest, | |
It bears no light from purer world’s to this;15 | |
Thy future lends not e’en a dream of bliss. | |
But who shall dare the Gate of Life to close, | |
Or say, thus far the stream of mercy flows? | 130 |
That font unseal’d, whose boundless waves embrace | |
Each distant isle, and visit every race, | |
Pours from the Throne of God its current free, | |
Nor yet denies th’immortal draught to thee. | |
Oh! while the doom impends, not yet decreed, | |
While yet th’Atoner hath not ceas’d to plead, | |
While still, suspended by a single hair,16 | |
The sharp bright sword hangs quivering in the air, | |
Bow down thy heart to Him, who will not break | |
The bruised reed; e’en yet, awake! awake! | 140 |
Patient, because Eternal,17 He may hear | |
Thy prayer of agony with pitying ear, | |
And send his chastening spirit from above, | |
O’er the deep chaos of thy soul to move. | |
But seek thou mercy thro’ His name alone, | |
To whose unequall’d sorrow none was shown. | |
Thro’ Him, who here in mortal garb abode, | |
As man to suffer, and to heal, as God; | |
And, born the sons of utmost time to bless, | |
Endur’d all scorn, and aided all distress. | 150 |
Call thou on Him—for He, in human form, | |
Hath walk’d the waves of Life, and still’d the storm.18 | |
He, when her hour of lingering grace was past, | |
O’er Salem wept, relenting to the last,19 | |
Wept with such tears as Judah’s monarch pour’d | |
O’er his lost child, ungrateful, yet deplor’d; | |
And, offering guiltless blood that guilt might live, | |
Taught from his Cross the lesson—to forgive! | |
Call thou on Him—his prayer e’en then arose, | |
Breath’d in unpitied anguish, for his foes.20 | 160 |
And haste!—ere bursts the lightning from on high, | |
Fly to the City of thy Refuge, fly!21 | |
So shall th’Avenger turn his steps away, | |
And sheath his falchion, baffled of his prey. | |
Yet must long days roll on, ere peace shall brood, | |
As the soft Halcyon, o’er thy heart subdued; | |
Ere yet the dove of Heaven descend, to shed | |
Inspiring influence o’er thy fallen head. | |
—He, who hath pin’d in dungeons, midst the shade | |
Of such deep night as man for man hath made, | 170 |
Thro’ lingering years; if call’d at length to be, | |
Once more, by nature’s boundless charter, free, | |
Shrinks feebly back, the blaze of noon to shun, | |
Fainting at day, and blasted by the sun!22 | |
Thus, when the captive soul hath long remain’d | |
In its own dread abyss of darkness chain’d, | |
If the Deliverer, in his might, at last, | |
Its fetters, born of earth, to earth should cast, | |
The beam of truth o’erpowers its dazzled sight, | |
Trembling it sinks, and finds no joy in light. | 180 |
But this will pass away—that spark of mind, | |
Within thy frame unquenchably enshrin’d, | |
Shall live to triumph in its brightening ray, | |
Born to be foster’d with etherial day.23 | |
Then wilt thou bless the hour, when o’er thee pass’d, | |
On wing of flame, the purifying blast, | |
And sorrow’s voice, thro’ paths before untrod, | |
Like Sinai’s trumpet, call’d thee to thy God! | |
But hop’st thou, in thy panoply of pride, | |
Heaven’s messenger, affliction, to deride? | 190 |
In thine own strength unaided to defy, | |
With Stoic smile, the arrows of the sky?24 | |
Torn by the vulture, fetter’d to the rock, | |
Still, Demigod! the tempest wilt thou mock?25 | |
Alas! the tower that crests the mountain’s brow, | |
A thousand years may awe the vale below, | |
Yet not the less be shattered on its height, | |
By one dread moment of the earthquake’s might! | |
A thousand pangs thy bosom might have borne, | |
In silent fortitude, or haughty scorn, | 200 |
Till comes the one, the master-anguish, sent | |
To break the mighty heart that ne’er was bent. | |
Oh! what is nature’s strength? the vacant eye, | |
By mind deserted, hath a dread reply! | |
The wild delirious laughter of despair, | |
The mirth of frenzy26—seek an answer there! | |
Turn not away, tho’ pity’s cheek grow pale, | |
Close not thine ear against their awful tale. | |
They tell thee reason, wandering from the ray | |
Of Faith, the blazing pillar of her way,27 | 210 |
In the mid-darkness of the stormy wave, | |
Forsook the struggling soul she could not save!28 | |
Weep not, sad moralist! o’er desert plains, | |
Strew’d with the wrecks of grandeur29—mouldering fanes | |
Arches of triumph, long with weeds o’ergrown, | |
And regal cities, now the serpent’s own: | |
Earth has more awful ruins—one lost mind, | |
Whose star is quench’d,30 hath lessons for mankind, | |
Of deeper import than each prostrate dome, | |
Mingling its marble with the dust of Rome.31 | 220 |
But who with eye unshrinking shall explore | |
That waste, illum’d by reason’s beam no more? | |
Who pierce the deep, mysterious clouds that roll | |
Around the shatter’d temple of the soul, | |
Curtain’d with midnight? low its columns lie, | |
And dark the chambers of its imag’ry,32 | |
Sunk are its idols now—and God alone | |
May rear the fabrick, by their fall o’erthrown! | |
Yet, from its inmost shrine, by storms laid bare, | |
Is heard an oracle that cries—“Beware! | 230 |
Child of the dust! but ransom’d of the skies! | |
One breath of Heaven—and thus thy glory dies! | |
Haste, ere the hour of doom, draw night to Him | |
Who dwells above between the cherubim!” | |
Spirit dethroned! and check’d in mid career, | |
Son of the morning! exil’d from thy sphere, | |
Tell us thy tale!—Perchance thy race was run | |
With Science, in the chariot of the sun; | |
Free as the winds the paths of space to sweep, | |
Traverse the untrodden kingdoms of the deep, | 240 |
And search the laws that nature’s springs controul,33 | |
There tracing all—save Him who guides the whole! | |
Haply thine eye its ardent glance had cast34 | |
Thro’ the dim shades, the portals of the past; | |
By the bright lamp of thought thy care had fed | |
From the far beacon-lights of ages fled, | |
The depths of time exploring, to retrace | |
The glorious march of many a vanish’d race. | |
Or did thy power pervade the living lyre, | |
Till its deep chords became instinct with fire, | 250 |
Silence all meaner notes, and swell’d on high, | |
Full and alone, their mighty harmony, | |
While wore each passion from its cell profound, | |
And nations startled at th’electric sound?35 | |
Lord of th’Ascendant! what avails it now, | |
Tho’ bright the laurels wav’d upon thy brow? | |
What, tho’ thy name, thro’ distant empires heard, | |
Bade the heart wound, as doth a battle-word? | |
Was it for this thy still unwearied eye, | |
Kept vigil with the watch-fires of the sky, | 260 |
To make the secrets of all ages thine, | |
And commune with majestic thoughts that shine | |
O’er Time’s long shadowy pathway?—hath thy mind | |
Sever’d its lone dominions from mankind, | |
For this to woo their homage?—Thou hast sought | |
All, save the wisdom with salvation fraught, | |
Won every wreath—but that which will not die, | |
Nor aught neglected—save eternity! | |
And did all fail thee, in the hour of wrath, | |
When burst th’o’erwhelming vials on thy path? | 270 |
Could not the voice of Fame inspire thee then, | |
O spirit! scepter’d by the sons of men,36 | |
With an Immortal’s courage, to sustain | |
The transient agonies of earthly pain? | |
—One, one there was, all-powerful to have sav’d, | |
When the loud fury of the billow rav’d; | |
But Him thou knew’st not—and the light he lent | |
Hath vanish’d from its ruin’d tenement, | |
But left thee breathing moving, lingering yet, | |
A thing we shrink from—vainly to forget! | 280 |
—Lift the dread veil no further—hide, oh! hide | |
The bleeding form, the couch of suicide!37 | |
The dagger, grasp’d in death—the brow, the eye, | |
Lifeless, yet stamp’d with rage and agony; | |
The soul’s dark traces left in many a line | |
Graved on his mien, who died,—“and made no sign!” | |
Approach not, gaze not—lest thy fever’d brain, | |
Too deep that image of despair retain; | |
Angels of slumber! o’er the midnight hour, | |
Let not such visions claim unhallow’d power, | 290 |
Lest the mind sink with terror, and above | |
See but th’Avenger’s arm, forgot th’Atoner’s love! | |
O Thou! th’unseen, th’all seeing!—Thou whose ways | |
Mantled with darkness, mock all finite gaze, | |
Before whose eyes the creatures of Thy hand, | |
Seraph and man, alike in weakness stand, | |
And countless ages, trampling into clay | |
Earth’s empires on their march, are but a day; | |
Father of worlds unknown, unnumber’d!—Thou, | |
With whom all time is one eternal now, | 300 |
Who know’st no past, no future—Thou whose breath | |
Goes forth, and bears to myriads, life or death!38 | |
Look on us, guide us!—wanderers of a sea | |
Wild and obscure, what are we, reft of Thee? | |
A thousand rocks, deep-hid, elude our sight, | |
A star may set—and we are lost in night; | |
A breeze may waft us to the whirlpool’s brink, | |
A treach’rous song allure us39—and we sink! | |
Oh! by His love, who, veiling Godhead’s light, | |
To moments circumscrib’d the Infinite, | 310 |
And Heaven and Earth disdain’d not to ally | |
By that dread union—Man with Deity; | |
Immortal tears o’er mortal woes who shed, | |
And, e’er he rais’d them, wept above the dead; | |
Save, or we perish!40—let Thy word controul | |
The earthquakes of that universe—the soul: | |
Pervade the depths of passion—speak once more | |
The mighty mandate, guard of every shore, | |
“Here shall thy waves be staid”——in grief, in pain, | |
The fearful poise of reason’s sphere maintain, | 320 |
Thou, by whom suns are balanced!—thus secure | |
In Thee shall Faith and Fortitude endure; | |
Conscious of thee, unfaltering shall the dust | |
Look upward still, in high and holy trust, | |
And, by affliction guided to Thy shrine, | |
The first, last thought of suffering hearts be Thine. | |
And oh! be near, when cloth’d with conquering power, | |
The King of Terrors claims his own dread hour: | |
When, on the edge of that unknown abyss, | |
Which darkly parts us from the realm of bliss, | 330 |
Awe-struck alike the timid and the brave, | |
Alike subdued the monarch and the slave, | |
Must drink the cup of trembling41—when we see | |
Nought in the universe but death and Thee, | |
Forsake us not;—if still, when life was young, | |
Faith to Thy bosom, as her home, hath sprung, | |
If Hope’s retreat hath been, through all the past, | |
The shadow by the Rock of Ages cast, | |
Father, forsake us not!—when tortures urge | |
The shrinking soul to that mysterious verge, | 340 |
When from Thy justice to Thy Love we fly, | |
On Nature’s conflict look with pitying eye, | |
Bid the strong, the fire, the earthquake cease, | |
Come in the still small voice,42 and whisper—peace! | |
For oh! ’tis awful—He that hath beheld | |
The parting spirit, by its fears repell’d, | |
Cling weak terror, to its earthly chain, | |
And from the dizzy brink recoil, in vain; | |
He that hath seen the last convulsive throe | |
Dissolve the union form’d and clos’d in woe, | 350 |
Well knows, that hour is awful.—In the pride | |
Of youth and health, by sufferings yet untried, | |
We talk of Death, as something which ’twere sweet | |
In Glory’s arms exultingly to meet, | |
A closing triumph, a majestic scene, | |
Where gazing nations watch the hero’s mien, | |
As, undismay’d amidst the tears of all, | |
He folds his mantle, regally to fall! | |
Hush, fond enthusiast!—still, obscure, and lone, | |
Yet not less terrible because unknown, | 360 |
Is the last hour of thousands—they retire | |
From life’s throng’d path, unnoticed to expire,43 | |
As the light leaf, whose fall to ruin bears | |
Some trembling insect’s little world of cares, | |
Descends in silence—while around waves on | |
The mighty forest, reckless what is gone! | |
Such is man’s doom—and, ere an hour be flown, | |
—Start not, thou trifler! such may be thine own. | |
But as life’s current in its ebb draws near | |
The shadowy gulph, there wakes a thought of fear, | 370 |
A thrilling thought, which, haply mock’d before, | |
We fain would stifle—but it sleeps no more! | |
There are, who fly its murmurs midst the throng, | |
That join the masque of revelry and song, | |
Yet still Death’s image, by its power restor’d, | |
Frowns midst the roses of the festal board, | |
And, when deep shades o’er earth and ocean brood, | |
And the heart owns the might of solitude, | |
Is its low whisper heard?—a note profound, | |
But wild and startling as the trumpet-sound, | 380 |
That bursts, with sudden blasts, the dead repose | |
Of some proud city, storm’d by midnight foes! | |
Oh! vainly reason’s scornful voice would prove | |
That life hath nought to claim such lingering love, | |
And ask, if e’er the captive, half unchain’d, | |
Clung to the links which yet his step restrain’d? | |
In vain philosophy, with tranquil pride, | |
Would mock the feelings she perchance can hide, | |
Call up the countless armies of the dead, | |
Point to the pathway beaten by their tread, | 390 |
And say—“What wouldst thou? Shall the fix’d decree, | |
Made for creation, be revers’d for thee?44 | |
—Poor, feeble aid!—proud Stoic! Ask not why, | |
It is enough, that nature shrinks to die! | |
Enough, that horror, which thy words upbraid, | |
Is her dread penalty, and must be paid! | |
—Search thy deep wisdom, solve the scarce defin’d | |
And mystic questions of the parting mind, | |
Half check’d, half utter’d—tell her, what shall burst | |
In whelming grandeur, on her vision first, | 400 |
When freed from mortal films?—what viewless world | |
Shall first receive her wing, but half unfurl’d? | |
What awful and unbodied beings guide | |
Her timid flight through regions yet untried? | |
Say, if at once, her final doom to hear, | |
Before her God the trembler must appear, | |
Or wait that day of terror, when the sea | |
Shall yield its hidden dead, and heaven and earth shall flee?45 | |
Hast thou no answer?—then deride no more | |
The thoughts that shrink, yet cease not to explore | 410 |
Th’unknown, th’unseen, the future—tho’ the heart, | |
As at unearthly sounds, before them start, | |
Tho’ the frame shudder, and the spirit sigh, | |
They have their source in immortality! | |
Whence, then, shall strength, which reason’s aid denies, | |
An equal to the mortal conflict rise? | |
When, on the swift pale horse,46 whose lightning pace, | |
Where’er we fly, still wins the dreadful race, | |
The mighty rider comes—oh! whence shall aid | |
Be drawn, to meet his rushing, undismay’d? | 420 |
—Whence, but from thee, Messiah!—thou hast drain’d | |
The bitter cup,47 till not the dregs remain’d, | |
To thee the struggle and the pang were known, | |
The mystic horror—all became thine own! | |
But did no hand celestial succour bring, | |
Till scorn and anguish haply lost their sting? | |
Came not th’Archangel, in the final hour, | |
To arm thee with invulnerable power? | |
No, Son of God! upon thy sacred head, | |
The shafts of wrath their tenfold fury shed, | 430 |
From man averted—and thy path on high, | |
Pass’d thro’ the strait of fiercest agony; | |
For thus th’Eternal, with propitious eyes, | |
Receiv’d the last, th’almighty sacrifice! | |
But wake! be glad, ye nations! from the tomb, | |
Is won the victory,48 and is fled the gloom! | |
The vale of death in conquest hath been trod,49 | |
Break forth in joy, ye ransom’d! saith your God! | |
Swell ye the raptures of the song afar, | |
And hail with harps your bright and morning star.50 | 440 |
He rose! the everlasting gates of day, | |
Receiv’d the King of Glory on his way! | |
The hope, the comforter of those who wept, | |
And the first fruits of them, in Him that slept.51 | |
He rose, he triumph’d! He will yet sustain | |
Frail nature sinking in the strife of pain. | |
Aided by him, around the martyr’s frame | |
When fiercely blazed a living shroud of flame, | |
Hath the firm soul exalted, and the voice | |
Rais’d the victorious hymn, and cried, Rejoice! | 450 |
Aided by Him, tho’ none the bed attend, | |
Where the lone sufferer dies without a friend, | |
He, whom the busy world shall miss no more, | |
Than morn one dew-drop from her countless store, | |
Earth’s most neglected child, with trusting heart, | |
Call’d to the hope of glory, shall depart! | |
And say, cold Sophist! If by thee bereft | |
Of that high hope, to misery what were left? | |
But for the vision of the days to be, | |
But for the Comforter, despis’d by thee, | 460 |
Should we not wither at the Chastener’s look, | |
Should we not sink beneath our God’s rebuke, | |
When o’er our heads the desolating blast, | |
Fraught with inscrutable decrees, hath pass’d, | |
And the stern power who seeks the noblest prey, | |
Hath call’d our fairest and our best away? | |
Should we not madden, when our eyes behold | |
All that we lov’d in marble stillness cold, | |
No more responsive to our smile or sigh, | |
Fix’d—frozen—silent—all mortality! | 470 |
But for the promise, all shall yet be well, | |
Would not the spirit in its pangs rebel, | |
Beneath such clouds as darken’d, when the hand | |
Of wrath lay heavy on our prostrate land, | |
And thou,52 just lent thy gladden’d isles to bless, | |
Then snatch’d from earth with all thy loveliness, | |
With all a nation’s blessings on thy head, | |
O England’s flower! wert gather’d to the dead? | |
But Thou didst teach us. Thou to every heart, | |
Faith’s lofty lesson did thyself impart! | 480 |
When fled the hope thro’ all thy pangs which smiled, | |
When thy young bosom, o’er thy lifeless child, | |
Yearn’d with vain longing—still thy patient eye, | |
To its last light, beam’d holy constancy! | |
Torn from a lot in cloudless sunshine cast, | |
Amidst those agonies—thy first and last, | |
Thy pale lip, quivering with convulsive throes, | |
Breath’d not a plaint—and settled in repose; | |
While bow’d thy royal head to Him, whose power | |
Spoke in the fiat of that midnight hour, | 490 |
Who from the brightest vision of a throne, | |
Love, glory, empire, claim’d thee for his own, | |
And spread such terror o’er the sea-girt coast, | |
As blasted Israel, when her Ark was lost! | |
“It is the will of God!”—yet, yet we hear | |
The words which clos’d thy beautiful career, | |
Yet should we mourn thee in thy blest abode, | |
But for that thought—“It is the will of God!” | |
Who shall arraign th’Eternal’s dark decree, | |
If not one murmur then escaped from thee? | 500 |
Oh! still, tho’ vanishing without a trace, | |
Thou hast not left one scion of thy race, | |
Still may thy memory bloom our vales among, | |
Hallow’d by freedom, and enshrin’d in song! | |
Still may thy pure, majestic spirit dwell, | |
Bright on the isles which lov’d they name so well, | |
E’en as an angel, with presiding care, | |
To wake and guard thine own high virtues there. | |
For lo! the hour when storm-presaging skies, | |
Call on the watchers of the land to rise, | 510 |
To set the sign of fire on every height,53 | |
And o’er the mountains rear, with patriot might, | |
Prepar’d, if summon’d, in its cause to die, | |
The banner of our faith, the Cross of victory! | |
By this hath England conquer’d—field and flood | |
Have own’d her sovereignty—alone she stood, | |
When chains o’er all the sceptred earth were thrown, | |
In high and holy singleness, a one, | |
But mighty, in her God—and shall she now | |
Forget before th’Omnipotent to bow? | 520 |
From the bright fountain of her glory turn, | |
Or bid strange fire upon his altars burn? | |
No! sever’d land, midst rocks and billows rude, | |
Thron’d in thy majesty of solitude, | |
Still in the deep asylum of thy breast, | |
Shall the pure elements of greatness rest, | |
Virtue and faith, the tutelary powers, | |
Thy hearths that hallow, and defend thy towers! | |
Still, where thy hamlet-vales, O chosen isle! | |
In the soft beauty of their verdure smile, | 530 |
Where yew and elm o’ershade the lowly fanes, | |
That guard the peasant’s records and remains, | |
May the blest echoes of the Sabbath-bell, | |
Sweet on the quiet of the woodlands swell, | |
And from each cottage-dwelling of thy glades, | |
When starlight glimmers through the deepening shades, | |
Devotion’s voice in choral hymns arise, | |
And bear the Land’s warm incense to the skies. | |
There may the mother, as with anxious joy, | |
To Heaven her lessons consecrate her boy, | 540 |
Teach his young accents still th’immortal lays, | |
Of Zion’s bards, in inspiration’s days, | |
When Angels, whispering through the cedar’s shade, | |
Prophetic tones to Judah’s harp convey’d; | |
And as, her soul all glistening in her eyes, | |
She bids the prayer of infancy arise, | |
Tell of His name, who left his Throne on high, | |
Earth’s lowliest lot to bear and sanctify, | |
His love divine, by keenest anguish tried, | |
And fondly say—“My child, for thee He died!” | 550 |
Appendix: Byron’s Stanzas from Childe Harold IV, on the Death of Princess Charlotte
167. | |
Hark! forth from the abyss a voice proceeds, | |
A long low distant murmur of dread sound, | |
Such as arises when a nation bleeds | |
With some deep and immedicable wound; | |
Through storm and darkness yawns the rending ground, | |
The gulf is thick with phantoms, but the chief | |
Seems royal still, though with her head discrowned, | |
And pale, but lovely, with maternal grief | |
She clasps a babe, to whom her breast yields no relief. | |
168. | |
Scion of chiefs and monarchs, where art thou? | |
Fond hope of many nations, art thou dead? | |
Could not the grave forget thee, and lay low | |
Some less majestic, less beloved head? | |
In the sad midnight, while thy heart still bled, | |
The mother of a moment, o’er thy boy, | |
Death hushed that pang for ever: with thee fled | |
The present happiness and promised joy | |
Which filled the imperial isles so full it seemed to cloy. | |
169. | |
Peasants bring forth in safety. – Can it be, | |
Oh thou that wert so happy, so adored! | |
Those who weep not for kings shall weep for thee, | |
And Freedom’s heart, grown heavy, cease to hoard | |
Her many griefs for ONE; for she had poured | |
Her orisons for thee, and o’er thy head | |
Beheld her Iris. – Thou, too, lonely lord, | |
And desolate consort – vainly wert thou wed! | |
The husband of a year! the father of the dead! | |
170. | |
Of sackcloth was thy wedding garment made; | |
Thy bridal’s fruit is ashes: in the dust | |
The fair-haired Daughter of the Isles is laid, | |
The love of millions! How we did intrust | |
Futurity to her! and, though it must | |
Darken above our bones, yet fondly deemed | |
Our children should obey her child, and blessed | |
Her and her hoped-for seed, whose promise seemed | |
Like stars to shepherds’ eyes: – ’twas but a meteor beamed. | |
171. | |
Woe unto us, not her; for she sleeps well: | |
The fickle reek of popular breath, the tongue | |
Of hollow counsel, the false oracle, | |
Which from the birth of monarchy hath run | |
Its knell in princely ears, till the o’erstung | |
Nations have armed in madness, the strange fate | |
Which tumbles mightiest sovereigns, and hath flung | |
Against their blind omnipotence a weight | |
Within the opposing scale, which crushes soon or late, – | |
172. | |
These might have been her destiny; but no, | |
Our hearts deny it: and so young, so fair, | |
Good without effort, great without a foe; | |
But now a bride and mother – and now there! | |
How many ties did that stern moment tear! | |
From thy Sire’s to his humblest subject’s breast | |
Is linked the electric chain of that despair, | |
Whose shock was as an earthquake’s, and opprest | |
The land which loved thee so that none could love thee best. |
|
Quoted Paula R. Feldman, The Poet and the Profits: Felicia Hemans and the Literary Marketplace, Keats-Shelley Journal XLVI 1997, p.156. |
|
|
BLJ VII 113, to Murray, June 7th 1820. |
|
|
The Edinburgh Monthly Review, 3 (April 1820) from pp. 373-83, quoted Susan J. Wolfson (ed.) Felicia Hemans, Selected Poems, Letters, Reception Materials, (Princeton University Press, 2000) p. 535. |
|
|
The opening paragraph echoes Manfred, I ii, 30-7: An Eagle passes. Manfred: Thou winged and cloud-clearing Minister! Whose happy flight is highest into heaven! Well mayst thou swoop so near me—I should be Thy prey, and gorge thine Eaglets; thou art gone Where the eye cannot follow thee, but thine Yet pierces downward—onward—or above – With a pervading vision: beautiful – How beautiful is all this visible World! |
|
|
Echoes Psalm 23, 4: Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I shall fear no evil … |
|
|
Echoes Paradise Lost V, when the Archangel Raphael visits prelapsarian Eden. |
|
|
Jesus’ words are at Matthew 7, 26: And every one that heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them not, shall be likened unto a foolish man, which built his house upon the sand … |
|
|
Don Juan III, The Isles of Greece, 9, 2: Fill high the Cup with Samian Wine! is written perhaps in reaction to Hemans’ words here. |
|
|
Matthew 26, 39: And he went a little farther, and fell on his face, and prayed, saying, O my Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me: nevertheless not as I will, but as thou wilt. |
|
|
Echoes Shakespeare, Sonnet 2, opening: When forty winters shall besiege thy brow, / And dig deep trenches in thy beauty’s field … |
|
|
For a possible target, see Don Juan II, 106, 7-8: As for the other two they could not swim, / So Nobody arrived on Shore but him. |
|
|
Hemans perhaps thinks here of the desertion of her husband to live in Italy. |
|
|
Echoes Shelley, Ozymandias: Look on my works, ye mighty! and despair! Hemans might, as a professional, have known Shelley’s poem, though few of her 1820 readers would have. |
|
|
Manfred, I i,12: The Tree of Knowledge is not that of Life. |
|
|
Echoes the encounter between Manfred and Astarte in II iv. |
|
|
Echoes (fortuitously) Pope, The Rape of the Lock II 28: And beauty draws us by a single hair. |
|
|
Hemans’ note: “He is patient, because He is eternal.” St. Augustine. |
|
|
For Jesus stilling the storm and walking on the water, see Matthew 14, 25; then Mark 4, 39 and Luke 8, 24. |
|
|
For Melchisedec, King of Salem, see Genesis 14, 18-20; and Hebrews 7, 1-4. |
|
|
Luke 23, 34: Then said Jesus, Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do. |
|
|
Hemans’ note: Then ye shall appoint you cities, to be cities of refuge for you: that the slayer may flee thither which killeth any person at unawares.—And they shall be unto cities of refuge from the avenger. –Numbers, chap. 35. |
|
|
Echoes B.’s The Prisoner of Chillon, final lines: …even I / Regained my freedom with a sigh. |
|
|
The previous ten lines would interpret The Prisoner of Chillon as an allegory of the spirit imprisoned in the flesh. See also Manfred, I ii 27: My own Soul’s Sepulchre … |
|
|
These four lines might refer to Manfred, who defies all the powers, celestial and infernal, alone; except that he never smiles while doing so. |
|
|
Refers to Prometheus, who, in this analysis, was wrong to defy Zeus and bring fire to men. |
|
|
Echoes Don Juan II, 79, 8-9: Tearing, and grinning, howling, screeching, swearing, / And, with Hyæna laughter, died despairing. Except that all these men have done is made the mistake of drinking sea-water. |
|
|
Echoes Exodus 13, 21: And the Lord went before them by day in a pillar of cloud, to lead them the way; and by night in a pillar of fire, to give them light … |
|
|
If this is a critique of Don Juan II, it ignores the fact that Juan, who will eat neither his tutor nor his spaniel, and who is courageous in the wreck, is the only one to survive, and re-enters a kind of paradise. |
|
|
Another possible reference to Ozymandias. |
|
|
Would refer to Manfred, except that his birth-star is not “quenched”, but condemned to be A wandering Hell in the eternal Space (I i 46). |
|
|
A general reference to the picture of Imperial Rome in Childe Harold IV. |
|
|
Hemans’ note: Every man in the chambers of his imagery.—Ezekiel, chap. 8. |
|
|
See Manfred’s confession to the Witch of the Alps about his ruthless quest for understanding (II ii 50-100). He does not, however, learn scepticism. |
|
|
This paragraph is about Manfred’s search for understanding: the next about Byron’s fame. Hemans conflates the fictional character with the contemporary man. |
|
|
That is, “Did you write poetry which made you famous the world over?” |
|
|
Hemans’ subtext widens to include Napoleon as well as B., who was never “sceptred” by anyone. |
|
|
Hemans may refer to the suicides of either Samuel Whitbread in 1815, or of Sir Samuel Romilly in 1818. |
|
|
“… death?” (First edition). |
|
|
Refers to Odysseus’ encounter with the Sirens in Odyssey XII; except that he makes sure that he cannot be allured by their song, and does not sink. |
|
|
The disciples’ cry on the Sea of Galilee: see Mark 4, 38 and Luke 8, 24. |
|
|
Hemans’ note: Thou hast drunk the dregs of the cup of trembling, and wrung them out.—Isaiah, chap. 51. |
|
|
Hemans’ note: And behold, the Lord passed by; and a great and strong wind rent the mountains, and brake in pieces the rocks before the Lord; but the Lord was not in the wind; and after the wind an earthquake; but the Lord was not in the earthquake; and after the earthquake a fire; but the Lord was not in the fire: and after the fire a still small voice. —Kings, book 1. Chap.19. |
|
|
Hemans, bookish in her inspiration as ever, may be thinking of Johnson’s Lines on the Death of Dr Robert Levet, except that she ignores the comfort Levet brought to dying people: In misery’s darkest caverns know / His useful care was ever nigh, / Where hopeless anguish pour’d his groan, / And lonely want retir’d to die. |
|
|
Echoes Johnson, The Vanity of Human Wishes, 156: Nor think the Doom of Man revers’d for thee. |
|
|
The poem’s only alexandrine. |
|
|
Revelation 6, 8: And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death, and Hell followed with him. |
|
|
See above, line 43n. |
|
|
I Corinthians, 15, 55: O death, where is thy sting? O grave, where is thy victory? |
|
|
See above, note to line 16. |
|
|
Psalm 81, 1-3: Sing aloud unto God our strength: make a joyful noise unto the God of Jacob. Take a psalm, and bring hither the timbrel, the pleasant harp with the psaltery. Blow up the trumpet in the new moon, in the time appointed, on our solemn feast day. Or Revelation 15,2: And I saw as it were a sea of glass mingled with fire: and them that had gotten the victory over the beast, and over his image, and over his mark, and over the number of his name, stand on the sea of glass, having the harps of God. |
|
|
I Corinthians, 15, 20: But now Christ is risen from the dead, and become the firstfruits of them that slept. |
|
|
Hemans apostrophises Princess Charlotte (1796-1817), only child of the Prince Regent and subject of Byron’s Weep, Daughter of a Royal Line; married to Prince Leopold of Saxe-Coburg, having previously broken off her engagement to Prince William of Orange. She had died in childbirth on 5th November 1817. See Childe Harold IV, stanzas 168-72 (printed below). |
|
|
Hemans’ note: And set up a sign of fire.—Jeremiah chap. 6. |

